Anaesthesia and Critical Care
Rapid Sequence
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Reviews
  • Links
  • About
    • The Team
    • The Rules
    • Confidentiality
    • Contact Us
    • Get Involved

Ketamine: raising the pressure?

20/2/2014

1 Comment

 
By John Weeks
Picture
Nitrous is a controversial topic, which Tom has already covered. Another one is Ketamine, Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI) and Intracranial Pressure (ICP). The teaching from multiple sources (books, colleges, guidelines etc) is that ketamine may increase the ICP and is therefore contra-indicated in TBI. However, there are strong advocates that ketamine does not cause a rise in ICP. 

Like most of these things my initial opinion was that if there is disagreement there is probably a lack of concrete evidence. Picking the right drug, for the right patient, at the right time (& being able to justify it) can be difficult. This is (partially) why I think this is a particularly interesting article.

Article: The Ketamine Effect on ICP in Traumatic Brain Injury

There are a lot of blogs covering this topic of sedative agents in TBI already so I won't go over old ground here, but links are included at the end for further reading. 

Tell me about the paper

This isn't the first article to look at ketamine & ICP in this context, nor by any means is it to first to question the 'ketamine raises the ICP' story, but it is a systemic review published very recently (Feb 2014) and worth a look.

What about the methodology?

They did a pretty comprehensive search of a large number of popular (and less popular) databases, as well as looking at proceedings of meetings and conferences etc. They posed a clear question of "In patients with TBI, what is the effect of ketamine on ICP", but also looked at secondary outcome measures including CPP, Mean Arterial Blood Pressure (MAP), patient outcome and adverse effects. Animal and non-English language studies were excluded. 
From 371 citations found they chose 7 articles, all prospective, with data on 156 patients (101 adult and 55 paediatric). 4 of the papers assessed ketamine infusions and 3 looked at bolus ketamine. All patients had severe TBI with a Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) < or equal to 8, and all were sedated and mechanically ventilated. 
The authors did a lot of work to get access to data not in journals (e.g. presented at conferences etc). 

What are their findings?

ICP didn't go up up. 
In the four infusion studies there was either no difference in the ICP or a very slight increase (2 mmHg), described as "statistically...yet not clinically significant". Two studies reported in increase in CPP (by as much as 8 mmHg) and one study reported a decreased vasopressor requirement.
In fact, in three of the studies it fell. In paediatric populations bolus doses of ketamine caused a fall in ICP of almost a third. For CPP, data were lacking in two of the studies but the third showed
There was a lack of quality outcome data (therefore long term effects were difficult to comment on), but the three studies reporting Glasgow Outcome Scale (GOS) reported the ketamine group was "comparable" in one study and "favourable" in another. 

Any problems/limitations?

There were no significant adverse events, and only two reports of non-clinically significant tachycardia.
The authors seem to have taken a pretty rigorous approach. Two individuals independently identified articles and then a similar approach was used for extracting data. 
However, inspite of their broad search, the numbers are small (only 156 patients, not enough for a meta-analysis) and there was considerable differences between the methodologies of the trial (heterogeneity). They calculate the strength of evidence against ICP elevation in TBI with ketamine as GRADE C, Oxford 2b.

So where does this fit in with the rest of the evidence?

Interesting question. The use of a sedative drug in TBI which is cardiostable and may potentially have neuroprotective effects (NMDA antagonism resulting in inhibition of glutamate activation and decreased nitric oxide (NO) levels) has a certain attractiveness.
Some of the older studies which reported a rise in the ICP assessed patients spontaneously breathing. The authors of this trial assert that this results in a rise in arterial carbon dioxide, causing cerebral vasodilation and therefore an increase in an ICP. 
We're left with a situation where some of the guidelines and textbooks are giving different advice to what's coming out in some of the literature (nothing new there...) A number of other articles (e.g. Chang et al., Filanovsky et al.)  have challenged the current thinking and perhaps in time opinions will change (after sufficient time for knowledge transfer). 
As is often the case, we're measuring a surrogate marker for 'badness'. Patients probably wouldn't really care if their ICP goes up, down, or stays the same, but rather if the outcome (e.g. neurological status) is improved. 


It would be interesting to see protocols from others regarding the use of ketamine and other sedative agents in TBI and polytrauma in other hospitals. 

Further reading

The PHARM run by Minh Le Cong ran a series on ketamine mythbusters, which included a podcast on the effects of ketamine on the ICP. There are some good links in the notes.
BestBets is full of great practical evidence advice. A bet done recently found:
"There is no evidence to suggest harm with Ketamine use as induction agent for the patient with potential traumatic brain injury. The drug has major advantages in those patients with associated haemodynamic compromise and should potentially be regarded as the agent of choice."
Andy Neill's Ketamine thoughts

LITFL on ketamine RSI in head injury

1 Comment

Etomideath: An Anaesthetic Horror Story (?)

10/2/2014

2 Comments

 
By Tom Heaton
Picture
It's a sunny weekday morning and the surgeons are elbow deep in an emergency laparotomy. The anaesthetic jobs are done and the patient is stable, needing only the regular glances at the monitors as input from us. The emergency list has been going well and I have had the chance to further practice my intubation skills. As a fairly new trainee at this point, I seize this lull in the otherwise busy day to make the most of the direct one-to-one consultant teaching available to us.
“Can I ask a bit more about etomidate as an induction agent? I’ve not actually seen it used yet.”
Silence descends upon the operating theatre. A peal of thunder rumbles ominously in the distance (I thought it was sunny!). Even the surgeons look up from the table, eyes widening above their facemasks. Someone drops a scalpel. 


Read More
2 Comments

Targeted Temperature Management after out of hospital cardiac arrest

9/2/2014

2 Comments

 
Picture
By John Weeks
There has been an explosion of conversation about Targeted Temperature Management (TTM) in post-arrest patients following the publication of the TTM trial by Nielson et al in the NEJM recently. 

Full article - Engl J Med 2013; 369:2197-2206 December 5, 2013



There has been loads of commentary and debate and I won't try to re-invent the wheel here.

Obviously I suggest you read the paper, listen to the podcasts and decide on your own opinion. However, I would probably summarise what I learnt as:
- HypERthermia after a cardiac arrest is probably bad (not contained in this paper but useful background knowledge)
- Controlling the temperature to 36°C may be the same as cooling the patient to 33°C, but we don't know that. We do know that there isn't a large difference.
- Studies to prove similarity between two interventions have to be massive (studies to show no difference can be smaller - MATHS fans)
- Cooling is an intervention and like any other thing we give (e.g. drugs) there is probably a dose-response relationship
- Neuroprognostication is difficult in the context of hypothermia and difficult post-cardiac arrest, and the two combined make things exceptionally tricky.

It may well be that different patients need different temperatures (for example patients with a long down-time and asystole might require longer at a lower temperature) - but clearly more studies are needed before this becomes practice.

Some links:
There's some useful background info on post-arrest hypothermia from Lewis Macken from SMACC 2013. This talk pre-dates the release of this trial but has some really interesting points, esp how small the numbers are in existing RCTs

A very readable summary from The Intensive Care Network

Interview with Nielson, the primary author of the study

St. Emlyn's info on the stats behind the trial

2 Comments

The Holy Trinity (Part 3)

6/2/2014

0 Comments

 
By Tom Heaton
Picture
Welcome back to the final part of our emergency surgery trilogy. In this series we have been looking at the ‘Big Three’ of emergency surgery: the ruptured AAA, the laparotomy, and the fractured hip. All three posts are based on the recent Anaesthesia supplement on the big three which you can get to through the link below (if you have managed to avoid it after the last few posts), focusing particularly on the elderly population. We wrap up with a look at those patients who have suffered a fractured hip, and all the problems that these patients encounter.


Read More
0 Comments

The Holy Trinity (Part 2)

2/2/2014

0 Comments

 
Picture
Welcome back to the second part of our look at the holy trinity of emergency surgery; a look at the three biggest operations and particularly focusing on their impact on the elderly population undergoing them. Today we turn our attention to the laparotomy, the go-to guy for all manner of intra-abdominal problems. As I mentioned in the last post, the basis for this blog post is the recent Anaesthesia supplement looking at ‘The Big Three’ of emergency surgery If you haven’t had a look at it yet check it out via the link below:


Read More
0 Comments

    The Blog

    A collection of our most recent posts on articles, guidelines and interesting thoughts.

    Archives

    February 2022
    May 2021
    March 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    October 2019
    August 2019
    June 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    October 2018
    March 2018
    November 2017
    May 2017
    February 2017
    July 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    November 2014
    September 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    July 2013
    May 2013

    Categories

    All
    Airway
    Allergy
    Anaemia
    Cases
    Clinical Reviews
    Critical Care
    DALES
    Education
    Epistemology
    Fluids
    Guidelines
    How Do We Know?
    Neuro
    NWRAG
    Pain
    Perioperative Medicine
    Regional
    Renal

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.